First performed in 1828 at the Teatro San Carlo in Naples, the work triumphed and went on to be performed multiple times, not only in Italy but all over Europe. And listening to this remarkable recording, as so often with Opera Rara ‘unveilings’, I find it difficult to fathom what caprices of fate ordained its short lifespan and subsequent eclipse.
Set in Imperial Rome under the rule of Emperor Tiberius, L’esule boasts one of the composer’s best bass-baritone roles, the Roman senator Murena. Sung here with great distinction by the Sicilian bass-baritone, Nicola Alaimo, the part was written for the superstar Luigi Lablanche (1794 – 1858), Queen Victoria’s voice coach and creator of the title role in Donizetti’s late comic masterpiece, Don Pasquale.
Roger Parker, Opera Rara’s Repertoire Consultant, and co-creator of the critical edition used in this recording. cites the work as one of Donizetti’s ‘break-through’ operas. Indeed, in his persuasive essay titled ‘The Yoke of the Finales: Donizetti’s Experimental Calling Card’, Parker challenges the long-held convention that Anna Bolena, written for Milan in 1830, marked the first of the composer’s serious operas to win international acclaim.
A stand-out first impression for me was the young Donizetti’s mastery of colourful orchestration, a trait he took on from his teacher, Giovanni Simone Mayr, whose own predilection for virtuoso writing within the ranks of his orchestral players is palpably evident in L’esule.
An early example of this is found in Alaimo’s introspective singing in Murena’s opening scene, [Cd 1 track 2], his burnished bass-baritone caressing the lovely contours of his cabaletta – the dramatic effect of the sung component shot through with Donizetti’s deploying glinting clarinet tones in his orchestral colouration. An epicurean sonic delight.
Domenico Gilardoni’s libretto for L’esule is recognisably a variation on the theme of the classic Androcles and the Lion legend. Here, however, we find Settimio, portrayed by the stylish Russian tenor, Sergey Romanovsky, emerging unscathed from the lion’s den, and able to renew ties with his love interest, Argelia.
As in her previous Opera Rara forays (Semiramide and Il Paria), Argelia, Murena’s empathetic daughter, is gorgeously sung by Albina Shagimuratova, whose father is guilt-stricken for exiling Settimio. That noted, there is no shortage of highlights to savour. Here are some examples.
Pomp and pageantry are key to Publio’s triumphal entrance march [CD 1 track 3], while track 6 has one being won over by the two lower-voiced male characters, Murena and Publio, pitting themselves against each other – forecasting pivotal moments in Verdi in decades to come.
For more riveting listening, sample track 9, to experience Settimo’s rapture, with Romanovsky in ardent mode in his aria ‘Aure di Roma!… Io vi respiro alfine!’ …Voi mi beate, in rammentar che Argelia, Le stesse ancor respira!…(Air of Rome!… At last I breathe you!.. You make me happy, reminding me, that Argelia also breathes it!.)
In track 11 Argelia makes her entrance duetting with Settimo to a lilting flute and harp-infused cantilena, another hark back that had me thinking of Rossini’s Armida and La donna del Lago, which both premiered at the San Carlo a decade earlier.
I’d also cite track 15, to savour the allure of ensemble singing that manifests in the trio for Murena, Argilia, and Settimio, with its sinuous clarinet obligato in the intro ‘ Ognun rimane, ove di nozze crede..’
Act 1 climaxes with a spectacular tutti finale [CD 1 track 21] ‘Piangi? Ti rasserena… Più aggravi il suo dolor!.’..(‘ You weep? Be calm…You make his sorrow worse!)…
Act 2 opens in Mureno’s house with a brief, hushed chorus, which ushers the man himself onto the scene, all mental distraction, his epic recitativo expressed in the fragmentary phrases as he sings ‘Al mio delitto!… ei… sì… qui… diè… perdono! Né vendetta! né amor! dovizie! nulla! (He… yes… here… pardoned… my crime! Not vengeance! nor love! nor wealth! Nothing!).
This morphs into Murena’s famous ‘Mad Scene’ [CD2 Track 2] followed by a brilliant cabaletta [3] Di Stige il flutto ancor.. Fra poco io varcherò! Throughout the scene, Alaimo displays his thrilling range, and coloratura technique, with knife-edge definition etched into his lightning swift divisions – a worthy successor indeed to the great Lablanche.
The Murena-Argilia duet ‘Vagiva Emilia ancora…E già… moria… la madre (Emilia was still wailing…And… her mother… had died…) sees Miss Shagimuratova soaring to a stratospheric D in alt. [CD2 Track 6]
Another moment I found myself reprising more than once was the plangent oboe in the introduction to Settimio’s scene and aria. Here, Donizetti’s shimmering strings and eery winds anticipate Verdi’s prelude to Lady Macbeth’s sleepwalking scene [CD 2 Tracks 8 to 10].
Indeed, at this juncture it is time for my full disclosure: Donizetti’s bejewelled score, married to the highs and lows of Gilardoni’s graphic libretto, left me replete in the conviction that this is a case of all’s well that ends well. Especially as the composer treats his soprano – and her audience – to a masterly display of bravura, with Miss Shagimuratova unleashing a splendid high C at the visceral climax of the Act 2 finale.
The rest of the cast, including upcoming soloists Kezia Bienek, Andre Henriques and Luis Calvet Pey, along with the Opera Rara Chorus and the Britten Sinfonia contribute mightily to this latest addition to Opera Rara’s discography. Rush forth and add it to your collection.

